The projects that tested many at once
12 studies12 studies in this index retested more than one of these effects, and between them they account for 63 of the 544 entries. The largest, Many Labs 2, settled 22 on its own.
A verdict on an entry page looks like its own small story. Often it is one row of a table in a paper that tested forty effects at once — and these are those papers, with everything each of them settled.
Many Labs 2 22 entries
7,205 participants · 64 sites
6 replicated · 10 mixed · 6 failed
- Affect heuristicMixed
- Asymmetry of similarityFailed to replicate
- Choosing versus rejectingFailed to replicate
- Construing actions as choicesFailed to replicate
- Cultural biasMixed
- Disfluency effectFailed to replicate
- Disgust sensitivity and moral judgementMixed
- False consensus effectReplicated
- Fundamental attribution errorReplicated
- Less-is-better effectReplicated
- Macbeth effectFailed to replicate
- Moral foundations theoryMixed
- Moral typecastingReplicated
- Probability neglectMixed
- Question order effectMixed
- Side-effect effectReplicated
- Social value orientationMixed
- Sociometric status and well-beingMixed
- Structure and goal pursuitFailed to replicate
- Tempting fateMixed
- Trolley problemReplicated
- Vertical position and powerMixed
Camerer (2018) 9 entries
234 participants · 1 sites
3 replicated · 3 mixed · 3 failed
- Automatic perspective takingMixed
- Aversion to being alone with one's thoughtsReplicated
- Clean slate effectFailed to replicate
- Expressive writing before a testFailed to replicate
- Google effectMixed
- Imagined consumptionReplicated
- Literary fiction and theory of mindMixed
- Overhead aversionReplicated
- Scarcity and cognitive functionFailed to replicate
Klein (2014) 8 entries
6,330 participants · 36 sites
7 replicated · 1 mixed · 0 failed
- Anchoring effectReplicated
- Forbid/allow asymmetryReplicated
- Framing effectReplicated
- Imagined contactMixed
- Implicit-explicit correspondenceReplicated
- Inverse gambler's fallacyReplicated
- Response scale range effectReplicated
- Sunk costReplicated
Many Labs 3 7 entries
2,285 participants · 20 sites
1 replicated · 4 mixed · 2 failed
- Elaboration likelihood modelMixed
- Embodied cognitionFailed to replicate
- Metaphoric structuring of timeMixed
- Power and perspective takingFailed to replicate
- Self-licensingMixed
- Stroop effectReplicated
- Temporal distancing biasMixed
Khemlani (2012) 3 entries
3 replicated · 0 mixed · 0 failed
- Fallacy of the undistributed middleReplicated
- Illicit majorReplicated
- Negative premise fallaciesReplicated
Ervas (2018) 2 entries
147 participants
2 replicated · 0 mixed · 0 failed
- EquivocationReplicated
- Fallacy of four termsReplicated
Lo Iacono (2022) 2 entries
1,636 participants
2 replicated · 0 mixed · 0 failed
- Hostile media effectReplicated
- Naive realismReplicated
Mayiwar (2025) 2 entries
623 participants
0 replicated · 2 mixed · 0 failed
Murphy (2023) 2 entries
123 participants
1 replicated · 1 mixed · 0 failed
- False memoryMixed
- Lost in the mall techniqueReplicated
Robbins (2005) 2 entries
5,053 participants
1 replicated · 1 mixed · 0 failed
- Psychological projectionMixed
- Social projectionReplicated
Ruggeri (2020) 2 entries
4,098 participants
1 replicated · 1 mixed · 0 failed
- Pseudocertainty effectReplicated
- Reflection effectMixed
Većkalov (2024) 2 entries
10,527 participants
0 replicated · 2 mixed · 0 failed
- Argument from authorityMixed
- Inflation of conflictMixed