Vol. I a living index of named laws · est. mmxxvi no ads · no tracking
The Law Tomeindex of named laws

The Prisoner's Dilemma

"Two rational players, each better off betraying, both betray and end up worse than if they had cooperated."
In plain English

What does The Prisoner's Dilemma mean?

Two self-interested players each choose to cooperate or defect. For each, defecting yields a higher payoff whatever the other does, so defection is a dominant strategy, and since both reason the same way, both defect and each ends up worse off than if both had cooperated. The dilemma is that individually rational choices produce a collectively worse outcome.

Reliability

Rated Empirical: grounded in studies or measurable evidence. The other 608.

Lineage
1950COINED
How it works

How does The Prisoner's Dilemma work?

The payoffs are ordered so that betraying a cooperator is best, mutual cooperation is next, mutual defection is worse, and being the betrayed cooperator is worst. Because betraying beats cooperating both when the other cooperates and when the other defects, defection strictly dominates. Mutual defection is therefore the unique Nash equilibrium, from which neither can improve alone, yet mutual cooperation would have paid both more. That gap between the equilibrium and the better joint outcome is the whole point.

Figure illustrating The Prisoner's Dilemma
The Prisoner's Dilemma — Jplotkin8 · CC BY-SA 3.0 · source
Where you'll see it

What are examples of The Prisoner's Dilemma?

Arms races Two nations are each better off arming whatever the other does, so both arm and both end up less secure and poorer than if both had disarmed: the classic strategic form of the dilemma.
Price wars Firms in a cartel each gain by secretly undercutting the agreed price, so all cut and all earn less than under mutual restraint: cooperation undone by the incentive to defect.
The iterated version When the game repeats, cooperation can emerge and persist through reciprocity, as Axelrod's tournaments showed: the shadow of the future changing what rational play looks like.
Types & variants

What are the types of The Prisoner's Dilemma?

The iterated prisoner's dilemma§

The game repeated over many rounds, where the prospect of future encounters can sustain cooperation through strategies like tit-for-tat, unlike the one-shot game.

The tragedy of the commons§

The multi-player generalisation, in which many users each rationally overuse a shared resource and collectively deplete it.

Why it matters

Why does The Prisoner's Dilemma matter?

It is the most famous model in game theory, capturing in a single structure why rational self-interest can defeat mutual benefit: from arms races and price wars to pollution and doping. It launched the formal study of cooperation and remains the reference point for understanding when and how self-interested parties fail, or manage, to work together.

Working with it

How do you apply The Prisoner's Dilemma?

  • Spot the dominant defection — identify situations where each party gains by defecting whatever the other does, and expect mutual defection despite a better joint outcome.
  • Change the game to cooperate — to escape the trap, alter the payoffs or repeat the interaction, since cooperation can hold when the future casts a long shadow.
  • Do not expect one-shot cooperation — in a genuine single encounter with no reputation at stake, treat mutual defection as the rational outcome.
Where it breaks down

What are the limits of The Prisoner's Dilemma?

The stark result applies to the one-shot game: in a single encounter with no communication or future, mutual defection is the unavoidable rational outcome. In repeated play with an uncertain end, cooperation can emerge and stabilise through reciprocity. Real people, including the earliest experimental subjects, cooperate substantially more than pure rational-choice theory predicts, even in one-shot settings. The model also assumes purely self-interested, rational players with common knowledge of payoffs that genuinely satisfy its ordering: where those fail, the predictions change, and the label is often applied loosely to cases that do not meet the formal conditions.

What it doesn't say

What are common misconceptions about The Prisoner's Dilemma?

It does not show that cooperation is always irrational: in the repeated game, reciprocity makes cooperation an equilibrium; the bleak result is specific to the one-shot version. And not every thwarted-cooperation situation is a true prisoner's dilemma; the label requires the specific payoff ordering.

Is it real?

Is The Prisoner's Dilemma real?

Yes, as far as the evidence goes. The Prisoner's Dilemma is rated Empirical here: it rests on studies or measurements rather than on a saying.

Rated from two sources. 609 of the 1,116 entries carry this rating. How the scale works.

Very widely printedin printed books: one of 22 names in its band, of 903 measured
46 of 111entries in economics & incentives carry the same rating

The best-known laws are the least likely to rest on measurement.

What pulls against it

What is the opposite of The Prisoner's Dilemma?

Nothing here is the formal negation of The Prisoner's Dilemma — these are the entries in this index that pull the other way, so that following both at once forces a choice.

Every opposing pair in the index.

Origin

Where did The Prisoner's Dilemma come from?

Devised by Merrill Flood and Melvin Dresher at the RAND Corporation in 1950; the prison-sentence story and the name came from Albert Tucker later that year, though the phrase first appears in print in Luce and Raiffa's 1957 text.

How the name spread

When did people start saying “The Prisoner's Dilemma”?

1800coined 19502019
How often “Prisoner 's Dilemma” appears in printed English, which takes hold around 1959 and peaks around 2007. Coined 1950 and in print by about 1959, unusually close together. This still charts the phrase rather than the idea. Source: Google Books Ngrams.
Known elsewhere as

What is The Prisoner's Dilemma called in other languages?

  • Arabicمعضلة السجينين
  • GermanGefangenendilemma
  • Spanishdilema del prisionero
  • Frenchdilemme du prisonnier
  • Hindiबंदी की दुविधा
  • Italiandilemma del prigioniero
  • Japanese囚人のジレンマ
  • Portuguesedilema do prisioneiro
  • Russianдилемма заключённого
  • Chinese囚徒困境

10 languages, as recorded on Wikidata. These are names the idea already goes by, not translations we made. The whole index by language.

Sources

Sources & further reading

  1. 1"Prisoner's Dilemma," Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy. — the payoff structure, dominance, the Nash equilibrium, and the iterated game.secondary
  2. 2Prisoner's dilemma, Wikipedia. — the Flood-Dresher origin, Tucker's story, the examples, and Axelrod's tournaments.secondary

Everything above traces to plato.stanford.edu and en.wikipedia.org: two secondary sources, accounts of the original rather than the original itself, which has not been located for this entry. Nothing is written from memory, and the method is written down. Spot an error or a better source? Suggest a fix.

What we checked

  • 1,116entries in the tomeListed one by one on the browse page.
  • 1,116of them citing a sourceOpen any entry: its sources sit at the foot of the page.
  • 2,489source references in allEach is named, and linked wherever the source is online.